Negotiating temporal uncertainty during late medieval pilgrimages to Jerusalem
linn eckhof
Late-medieval pilgrims travelling from Venice to Jerusalem faced weeks of unpredictable delays, revealing how temporal disruption, patience and religious time intertwined to make dis:connectivity a defining feature of the pilgrimage experience.Imagine you are excited to embark on a long journey. You have spared no effort or expense to make it all the way to Venice. However, Venice is just a short stopover on your journey, or so you thought. You are waiting at the Venice harbour; the ship is delayed. You open your travel app: a three-hour delay, it says, because of the weather. ‘Annoying, but oh well’, you think, before grabbing a coffee and waiting until it is time to set off. Now imagine you’re not waiting three hours, but three weeks. And now imagine there is no reliable information about the length of the delay or what will happen next. In the 15th century, this was the reality of late-medieval pilgrims to Jerusalem, who were forced to wait in Venice in a state of uncertainty for their galleys to depart. This waiting exemplifies dis:connectivity: although Venice functioned as a major hub connecting Europe with the eastern Mediterranean, pilgrims experienced the city as a space of suspended mobility, where connections were interrupted, delayed, and renegotiated.

Fig. 1: A Venetian galley that brought the pilgrims from Venice to Jerusalem (Beschreibung der Reise von Konstanz nach Jerusalem – Cod. St. Peter pap. 32 / Konrad Grünenberg, fol. 5v-6r, Baden State Library, Karlsruhe, https://digital.blb-karlsruhe.de/blbhs/content/pageview/7062094.)
The uncertain timing on late-medieval pilgrimages to Jerusalem
Numerous accounts of late-medieval pilgrims reveal that the pilgrimage to Jerusalem, which reached their quantitative peak in the second half of the 15th century,[1] involved movement through space as well as time – unpredictably. The temporal discontinuities of these journeys did not prevent pilgrims from travelling, but they fundamentally shaped their experiences. Even though late-medieval pilgrimages displayed professional organisation, and the connection between Venice and Jerusalem was established through the regular voyages, this connectivity was often interrupted, creating temporal uncertainty. The pilgrims knew, at best, an approximate departure time; however, even those were often inaccurate. Postponements of the ship’s departure and weeks of waiting in uncertainty were the rule. Venice thus served as a central waiting area on late-medieval pilgrimages.[2] The journeys to Jerusalem were about the spiritual practice of travelling as well as reaching the destination.[3] Whilst in Venice, the pilgrims visited holy sites, amongst other things, and watched processions. In their experience, therefore, travelling time and religious time became intertwined. The journeys were as much about building a physical and spiritual connection between Europe and the Holy Land as they were about exhibiting Christian virtues in dealing with disconnections, such as endurance in traversing long distances and suffering delays with patience. The aim of this essay is to show that the temporality of the journey, as well as the overlapping of different temporal layers, make late-medieval pilgrimages to Jerusalem a fascinating subject to study temporal dis:connectivity. Therefore, the following focuses on factors leading to temporal unpredictability, as well as on pilgrims’ coping strategies and emotional responses.Factors contributing to temporal uncertainty
Travel is inherently linked to the passing of time, but travel time does not always equal movement. Late-medieval pilgrims frequently experienced this through unexpected delays and halts. Despite growing professionalisation, temporal unpredictability remained central to their journeys, as it does to ours. Several impediments appear in the 14 pilgrim accounts from the second half of the 15th century that I studied. They can be divided into three categories: unpredictability caused by nature, by human action and by (other) external circumstances. Sea voyages are prone to the unpredictable forces of nature. Wind was vital and ranged from gentle, helpful breezes to dead calm to violent storms that drove galleys hundreds of kilometres off course. Heinrich von Zedlitz, a late-medieval pilgrim from Silesia who set out for Jerusalem in 1493, reported: ‘On Saturday […] we set sail and had a rough wind and could not sail far. We dropped anchor and stayed there overnight’.[4] Apart from the weather, the unfamiliar climate, especially the heat, often led to exhaustion and illness, which also caused delays. Human factors also contributed to temporal uncertainty. The pilgrims’ accounts mention that the patron of the galley did not adhere to the agreed departure times — a point we will revisit. Moreover, they mention encounters with pirates at sea as well as attacks and arrests by Muslims in the Holy Land. Paul Walther von Guglingen, who was travelling to Jerusalem from 1481 to 1484, wrote in his account that Muslims ‘kept [them] waiting for a good two hours’ close to Jericho.[5] Logistical difficulties, such as official registration in the Holy Land, waiting for companions and ship repairs also frequently forced pilgrims to wait. Felix Fabri undertook two pilgrimages, one in 1480 and one from 1481 to 1484, and he, for example, reported a broken rudder: ‘The rudder was already broken, we could not sail, but we brought the galley back into the harbour’.[6] So the pilgrims described many kinds of delay, but how did they react? Were they just as annoyed at the harbour as you might be?
Fig. 2: A view of the long-awaited city of Jerusalem in Konrad Grünemberg’s account (Beschreibung der Reise von Konstanz nach Jerusalem – Cod. St. Peter pap. 32 / Konrad Grünenberg, fol. 35v-36r, Baden State Library, Karlsruhe, https://digital.blb-karlsruhe.de/blbhs/content/pageview/7062118)
Between accepting and controlling temporal unpredictability
The pilgrims’ accounts reveal how they handled temporal unpredictability and its relation to nature, human action and external forces. Pilgrims recognised natural and external causes as unavoidable and therefore seemed to have accepted them. However, the problems caused by the human factor, like the patron of the galley, seem to have been less acceptable, as their attempts to regulate the patron’s behaviour by drawing up shipping contracts shows. In Venice, the pilgrims spent their sojourns visiting holy sites, stocking up on essentials for the journey and making important preparations, like booking passage on a galley.[7] They concluded contracts with the ships’ owners, which divulge how unpredictability was handled and negotiated. With these contracts, pilgrims attempted to gain control over temporal uncertainty by agreeing to fixed itineraries and predefined exceptions. Bernhard von Breydenbach, a canon of Mainz who travelled to Jerusalem in 1483-84, listed some such cases, including that the patron shall not stay at any place longer than two or three days, unless there was a strong wind or a storm at sea.[8] Some factors made scheduling impossible, which simply had to be accepted. Natural factors could override temporal clauses in contracts. There were also exemptions to Wilhelm Tzewers’s terms from his pilgrimage to the Holy Land in 1477-78: ‘The patron shall also depart without fail on the fixed day or established time, unless he is prevented by the authority of the Signoria, by stormy weather, or by severe illness’.[9] However, the unpredictability caused by the human factor — in this case, the patron — was resisted in both cases, as demonstrated by attempts to regulate his behaviour. This also explains the frustration expressed later in the accounts regarding the patron’s violation of the terms. Pilgrims’ journeys were subject to spatial and temporal constraints due to the deep professionalisation, as in shipping contracts that included board and lodging. While these arrangements provided pilgrims with some security, they also restricted their freedom to schedule their journey independently.What emotions arise from temporal unpredictability?
Speaking of frustration: remember our thought experiment? Think back to the notification on your phone. Your ship is late. That means three more hours of waiting. While you would have to be patient for three hours, the pilgrims had to be patient for weeks. As a Christian virtue, patience plays a central role in these pilgrim accounts. After all, pilgrimage was a religious practice. The pilgrims knew well that they ought to practice patience and, perhaps more importantly, display patience. Indeed, this was supposed to be an inherent part of the pilgrimage experience. Paul Walther emphasises the need patience throughout his account, resolving ‘to endure patiently whatever sweet Jesus might impose for His own praise’.[10] This emphasis on patience runs through various pilgrimage accounts, including those by Felix Fabri and Bernhard von Breydenbach. Even though patience was the ideal, emotional reactions to delays flash through the narratives. The most frequent reactions in the texts are sadness, gloom and discontent. In particular, the waiting period in Venice and during the sea voyage tested the pilgrims’ patience. Felix Fabri struggled with waiting in ‘Venice for such a long time and many more days, which was very burdensome’.[11] Hans Bernhard von Eptingen was sorrowful because of the lack of wind,[12] and Paul Walther ‘deeply grieved at the loss of […] the time’.[13] Pilgrims not only covered the distance to the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, their ultimate destination, but also an interval that often was longer than they had hoped.
Fig. 3: The long-awaited holy site in Jerusalem: the Church of the Holy Sepulchre (Beschreibung der Reise von Konstanz nach Jerusalem – Cod. St. Peter pap. 32 / Konrad Grünenberg, fol. 43v-44r, Baden State Library, Karlsruhe, https://digital.blb-karlsruhe.de/blbhs/content/pageview/7062119.)
Conclusion
So, when will this ship depart? Today, real-time updates leave little room for uncertainty. There you are again at the harbour, coffee in hand, waiting another hour for the ship. You’re annoyed by the delay, but you’ll manage to keep yourself entertained somehow. However far we take this thought experiment, we know that, despite new technologies, delays and interruptions remain part of travel, though nowhere near to the extent experienced by late-medieval pilgrims travelling to Jerusalem (perhaps a thought that will make it easier to wait next time). The late-medieval pilgrimage, which linked pilgrims’ homes in Europe with distant Jerusalem, was characterised by deep uncertainty about the journey’s duration. Human factors, natural and other circumstances demanded patience from the pilgrims. The shipping contracts for the voyage from Venice to Jaffa illustrate attempts to make itineraries more predictable and reliable by limiting delays caused the ships’ patrons. Yet despite these contracts, patrons regularly disregarded the agreed timeframes, which highlights the limits of temporal control and the need for patience. Even though late-medieval pilgrimages were characterised by professional organisation, and even though there was a physical link — a connection — between Venice and Jerusalem over the sea, pilgrims experienced that connection as fraught with interruptions. Temporal discontinuities were thus themselves a structuring element of late-medieval pilgrimages. Intervals of waiting were spent, amongst other things, visiting holy sites, which embedded them in a religious timeframe. These periods could become part of the religious experience (‘the journey is the destination’). Long waiting times, perseverance and patience became means of demonstrating piety. Thus, pilgrimages offer a fascinating example not only of geographical connections and their interruptions, but also of temporal ones: brief interruptions provided an opportunity to imbue this time with religious significance and thus established a strong link to religious time. Here, disconnection and connection coexisted. The geographical and spiritual connection between the homeland and the Holy Land therefore did not arise in spite of these temporal interruptions and delays, but precisely because of them.[Published 27.10.2026 temporal dis:connectivity is a blog series that explores how concepts and experiences of time shape global processes across time and space. In this series, scholars from different disciplines ask what attention to temporality can reveal about globalisation, historical change, and the ways societies imagine the past, present, and future. For the previous entry in this series on temporal dis:connectivity, click here. To read the introduction to the series, click here.]
[1] Ludwig Schmugge, 'Die Pilger', in Unterwegssein im Spätmittelalter, ed. Peter Moraw (Berlin: Duncker & Humblot, 1985), 25. [2] Ursula Ganz-Blätter, '"Ich kam, sah und berührte". Jerusalem als Pilgerziel im ausgehenden Mittelalter', in Pilgerreisen in Mittelalter und Renaissance, ed. Barbara Haupt and Wilhelm G. Busse (Düsseldorf: Droste Verlag., 2006), 18. [3] Andrea Denke, Venedig als Station und Erlebnis auf den Reisen der Jerusalempilger im späten Mittelalter (Remshalden: Verlag Manfred Hennecke, 2001). [4] Reinhold Röhricht, 'Die Jerusalemfahrt des Heinrich von Zedlitz (1493)', Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palaestina-Vereins 17 (1894): 294. Unless otherwise indicated, all translations are the author’s. Original: ‘Item am Sonnabende […] furen wir darvonn vnd haten bösen windt vnd Konden nicht wait gefaren vnd worffen Ancker vnd plieben die nacht do liegen’. [5] Paul Walther von Guglingen, Fratris Pauli Waltheri Guglingensis: Itinerarium in terram sanctam et ad sanctam Catharinam, ed. M. Wollweck (Tübingen: Bibliothek des litterarischen Vereins in Stuttgart, 1892), 168. Original: ‘Cum descendimus montes ad planitiem versus Jericho, erat bene hora decima in nocte, tunc ipsi maledicti Mauri delinaverunt a via versus Quarentanam, et duxerunt nos iuxta Jericho, et ibi fecerunt stare bene per duas horas […].’ [6] Felix Fabri, Les Errances de frère Félix, pèlerin en Terre sainte, en Arabie et en Égypte, vol. 1 (Paris: Classiques Garnier, 2013), 202–04. Original: ‘Et quia temo iam ruptum erat, nauigare non poteramus, sed galeam reinduximus in portum ad locum ubi prius steterat’. [7] Denke, Venedig als Station. [8] Bernhard von Breydenbach, Peregrinatio in terram sanctam. Eine Pilgerreise ins Heilige Land. Frühneuhochdeutscher Text und Übersetzung (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2012), 59. Original: ‘Auch ſol der patron an alle ſtett vn̄ porten faren do man gewonlıchen hyn pflegt zů faren∙vnd ſoll auch an keyner ſtatt lenger nit verharren dan zwen oder dry tag∙eß were dan groſſer wynt oder fortuna vſſ dem meer’. [9] Gritje Hartmann, ed., Wilhelm Tzewers - Itinerarius terre sancte. Einleitung, Edition, Kommentar und Übersetzung (Wiesbaden: Harrassowity Verlag, 2004), 79. Original: ‘Patronus eciam certo die aut termino statuto exibit sine fallo, nisi impeditus potestate senarie, tempestate aeris aut gravi infirmitate’. [10] Walther von Guglingen, Fratris Pauli, 123. Original: ‘[…] et finaliter omnia patienter ferre, que ipse dulcis Ihesus pro sua laude supermitteret.’ [11] Fabri, Les Errances, 1, 312. Original: ‘De omnibus autem eramus bene contenti, dempto illo quod tam longum tempus et multos dies adhuc nos Veneciis manere oportuit, quod erat nobis ualde graue’. [12] Dorothea Christ, Das Familienbuch der Herren von Eptingen: Kommentar und Transkription, Quellen und Forschungen zur Geschichte und Landeskunde des Kantons Basel-Landschaft, (Liestal: Verlag des Kantons Basel-Landschaft, 1992), 291. Original: ‘Item am Müttwochen do hatten wir gantz Bonatz, das ist kein Windt, und hatten auch Niena wasser, das thet unns betrüeben’. [13] Walther von Guglingen, Fratris Pauli, 213. Original: ‘Et exiverunt querere aliqui de nostris Arabis, nos vero stetimus ibi, multum dolentes de perditione tam bestiarum quam etiam temporis.’ [14] Hartmann, Wilhelm Tzewers, 118–29. Original: ‘Quartum de paciencia habenda. Et si quem ira vinceret, ut aliquem molestaret Morum, cito impendat operas, ut primam coram trotzmanno deferat querelam’.

